Y!: Mom of Girl Who Got ‘Catastrophe Award’ for Homework Excuses Responds to Parenting Critics

12 06 2012

This is absolutely a case of poor judgement on the teacher’s part. I’m all for having fun with students and playing jokes with them; even taking a little jab at them here and there. But there can be a lot of risk. First, you have to have a good relationship with the student, and know you can joke around with them. Also, you have to use the lighthearted moments as a way to encourage better performance and behavior.

I can see how a “negative award” might work, but this isn’t the way of doing it. I’ve had plenty of students who would aspire to get such an award, and revel in the attention that they get from it. Likewise, I know that many would get their feelings hurt, and I can see angry parents on both sides.

– dEV

#     #     #

By Lauren Sher | ABC News Blogs – Thu, May 31, 2012 6:57 PM EDT

The mother of an 8-year-old Arizona girl whose daughter was presented with a “Catastrophe Award” for having the most homework excuses in the class fired back against those criticizing her for poor parenting.

Christina Valdez first told ABC affiliate KGUN-TV that her third grade daughter, Cassandra Garcia, received the controversial award from her teacher in front of her classmates at the Desert Springs Academy in Tucson, Ariz.

Since the story was first reported, it has sparked a heated discussion online, with thousands weighing in on both sides. Many took issue with the teacher, saying that the award was completely inappropriate, but even more lashed out at the girl’s parents, asking why her mom and dad didn’t know that their daughter was having problems with her homework in the first place and didn’t check on her or take steps to help get her on track.

One commenter on the “Good Morning America” website said she deserves the “Out-of-Touch Mom of the Year” award and others told her to “step up as a parent.”

Valdez said she brushed off the harsh comments and insisted that she made sure that her daughter’s homework assignments were completed.

“It’s not the case that I was MIA. I am there 24-7 with my kids and they do have a routine that they follow with homework and things they have to do around the house,” she said, adding that she can only recall three or four times where her daughter’s assignments were left uncompleted over the course of the school year.

“There are a few assignments that weren’t turned in and that I didn’t know of because Cassandra didn’t write them in the homework book,” she said.

Her daughter had been enrolled in an after-school homework assistance program, where she completed the bulk of her assignments each day, Valdez added.

Valdez said she never imagined the story would “go viral” and that she just wanted an apology.

“All I ever wanted was just an apology, for the principal to acknowledge that [the award] wasn’t acceptable … and they have not yet apologized,” she  said.

A spokesperson from Desert Springs Academy could not be reached for comment for this story. The principal declined to comment to a KGUN reporter, who first covered the story.

Valdez said her daughter is still humiliated by the award, which looked like a colorful card and read: “You’re Tops! Catastrophe Award.  Awarded to Cassandra Garcia. For Most Excuses for Not Having Homework.” The teacher signed the card “Ms. Plowman,” added the date – May 18, 2012 – and even included a smiley face.

When she contacted the school to complain, Valdez said the principal told her it was a joke and that, “Some teachers joke around with the students.”

Some of Christina’s classmates received awards for superlatives such as “Math Wizard” and “Class Clown,” Valdez said, but she still didn’t find anything funny about her daughter’s award.

“If that’s the joke, then give her a ‘Miss Busybody’ Award or ‘Most Talkative in Class’ or something in that category, not ‘Catastrophe Award,'” Valdez said. “I’d rather her not receive any award and pout and complain. It’s just ridiculous.”

(Full Story with Video)





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: